On jacksons whole, however, clones are used as replacement bodies for the richwhich involves the inelegant, terrifying necessity of removing. Known worldwide as the standard introductory text to this important and exciting area, the sixth edition of gene cloning and dna analysis addresses new and growing areas of research whilst retaining the philosophy of the previous editions. This timely anthology offers a range of expert opinion, from scientific, religious western and nonwestern, philosophical, and legal points of view on all the major ethical issues surrounding this controversial subject. The fight for or against control, dislike or hatred of clones, and justification of cloning. Four fallacies and their legal consequences is a rollicking ride through science, psychology and the law. Apr 01, 2001 the european parliament urged britain to stop its cloning plans, and japan has enacted a law that would make cloning a crime punishable by up to ten years in jail.
While the bible does not specifically deal with the subject of human cloning, there are principles in scripture which may shed more light on the concept. List of books and articles about animal cloning online. Its a little light on the worldbuilding honestly, i would have liked a bit more. Apollo, scientific prodigy, feels thwarted in his attempts at cloning the longlost love of his life, and ponders about his mistakes, his past, his achievements, and how he plans to save humanity from annihilation. The genre is littered with them, usually in the form of either clone armies or evil doubles. Jaenisch makes public case against human cloning mit news. Eva has spent her whole life learning to be someone else. Yet one of tannerts major arguments against cloning is that genetic identity carries great weight.
Human cloning ebook by kerry lynn macintosh 97819854467. This article focuses on the ethics of cloning a human being for the purposes of producing a child or children in a family. Human cloning moral and ethical aspects united states. Or will the copies perhaps produced without heads be kept in storage to provide replacement organs. Jan 19, 2017 science fiction, as a rule, loves its clones. But it is not clear that cloning restricts the autonomy of the clone.
Politics world business tech health time health entertainment science newsfeed living sports history the time vault magazine ideas time labs photography videos the goods press room the 100 most influential people next generation leaders person of the year top of the world. Its really quite remarkable that it works at all, westhusin says. From this collection, readers will gain a clearer picture of the history of cloning in agriculture and. This category may require frequent maintenance to avoid becoming too large. Tofflers book was very much at the origin of the popular perception of cloning and its dangers. Futurist speaker and advisor to 400 of worlds largest companies. In the cloning sourcebook, raanan gillon examines the arguments against human reproductive cloning and concludes that a temporary ban is justified. Kazuo ishiguro shelved 61 times as cloning avg rating 3. Arguments against reproductive cloning and therapeutic. Or is it a practical avenue toward beneficial new medical treatments and techniques. Clones in fiction district of columbia public library. Exploring the controversy surrounding therapeutic human cloning, this book draws upon data collected from news articles. Kass, a professor at the university of chicago, contends that cloning experiments on humans are likely to produce. In these ten novels, clones are used as more than just plot devices, cannon fodder, or.
Arguments against reproductive cloning and therapeutic cloning. On the one hand, therapeutic cloning is based on a reproductive technology. At the same time, it confirms how difficult it would be to clone a random adult adolf hitler, say. List of books and articles about cloning online research. Perhaps we could also protect ourselves against diseases that jump from animals to people, such as mad cow disease. It is true, though, that cloning, used in conjunction with other biotechnologies. This site uses cookies to deliver our services, improve performance, for analytics, and if not signed in for advertising.
Twenty years after the first cloned animal, scientific progress remains messy, human, and often optimistic. I say if catholics are against cloning, then they are scared to be proven wrong. The quality of the public debate on human reproductive cloning has not been of a. The presentation of dolly the sheep and human cloning in the. Dec 01, 2001 in the cloning sourcebook, raanan gillon examines the arguments against human reproductive cloning and concludes that a temporary ban is justified. Egg retrieval is a complicated procedure, involving courses of hormone treatments and significant risks for the woman. The national academy of sciences, while supporting 2001 such socalled therapeutic or research cloning, has opposed 2002 the cloning of humans for reproductive purposes, deeming it unsafe, but many ethicists, religious and political leaders, and others have called for banning human cloning for any purpose. Arguments against cloning of companion animals have focused on the cost of producing a clonetens to hundreds of thousands of dollarswhen millions of unwanted dogs and cats are killed each year. First, dna is removed from the nucleus of a creatures cell. Up to 20 books are listed, in descending order of popularity.
Hence, some of the arguments against cloning are either specious or fuelled by ignorance. In this concise volume, experts on all sides of the debate make arguments for why we should either pursue, regulate, or ban the cloning of human beings. The first formal legislation against murder was grounded in the truth that people are in the image of god gen. Nancy farmer goodreads author shelved 51 times as cloning avg rating 4. Utilitarianism, exceptionality of clones, individuality, the fight for or against. This book highlights cloning from its natural origins to the present, including the early history of cloning, the cloning of the famous sheep, dolly, current cloning. And while lots of different kinds of animals have been. Cloning is often confused with other advances in biomedicine and bioengineering such as genetic selection. Cloning books showing 149 of 371 never let me go paperback by. This book is to prepare us for an unimaginably beautiful world turned. But the idea of making exact copies of deceased humans remains a delusion. The ability to successfully clone genes underlies the majority of our knowledge in molecular and cellular biology.
The story of dolly is about us as much as cloning new. Selected quotes on human cloning, compiled in april 2008 the holy see on human cloning, september 27, 2004 intervention by the holy see delegation at the general assembly of the united nations international convention against the reproductive cloning of human beings, october 21, 2004. Highly customised, very interactive, entertaining futurist presentations, every industry, 50 nations. Discover delightful childrens books with prime book box, a subscription that delivers new. The coming public conflict over human cloning wesley j. Among the novels futuristic inventions are clone power, whose. Large scale research cloning could generate a market for womens eggs that could easily lead to exploitation. Research cloning arguments pro and con center for genetics. Plants have carried on complex cloning in the natural world for billions of years, but it was not until the twentieth century that scientists first began artificial cloning. A girl, iris the clone, whining through 263 pages how bad it is to be a clone. Jan 27, 2018 pictures of the first two cloned primates have caused deep unease. The observer view on cloning observer editorial opinion.
A refreshingly comprehensive and balanced overview of the complex arguments, for and against, human cloning. On the scientific side, we see that a large percentage of cloning efforts end in failure. Yet human cloning is currently banned throughout the world, and therapeutic cloning banned in many countries. A book by the cell biologist and journalist helen pilcher cheerfully explores advances in cloning that could be used to revive departed species. First, though, there are plenty of kinks still to be worked out. For and against offers fiftyfour articles by scientists, ethicists, legal experts and religious leader who explore the many benefits and costs of cloning.
For example, some ethicists emphasize the physical danger that the technology poses to these children. Jul 07, 2015 the cloning of joanna may is a spellbinding novel about the elusive nature of identity, the consequences of playing god, and the ongoing struggle for power between women and men. Cloning would prove every religion wrong and say god or whoever it is is not the sout create of life god would cease to exist and the world would turn to turmoil. However, people currently buy purebred dogs and cats for thousands of dollars when they could get animals for no or low cost. Is human cloning a science fiction nightmare come true. Five reasons against farm animal cloning animal cultures. This book highlights cloning from its natural origins to the present, including the early history of cloning, the cloning of the famous sheep, dolly, current cloning controversies, and further developments in the field of. This study determined the themes found in the young adult fiction selected and if those themes reflected issues about human cloning. Since its conception,cloning has had people arguing different views on why cloning is either one ofthe greatest breakthroughs in the scientific world, or why it is a timebombwaiting to detonate. There are plenty of arguments against cloning especially against cloning humans ranging from scientific issues, to the practicality of cloning, to religious objections.
The ethics of human cloning hardcover june 1, 1998. A timely investigation into the ethics, history, and potential of human cloning from professor ian wilmut, who shocked scientists, ethicists, and the public in 1997 when his team unveiled dolly. Drawing on sources ranging from science fiction films to the congressional record, this book unmasks the role that psychological essentialism has played in bringing about cloning bans. In 2002, president bushs council on bioethics wrote a report arguing that reproductive cloning should be banned, but left the door open to allowing researchtherapeutic cloning. Jan 01, 2002 the technique of cloning has recently opened up two new possibilities.
Human cloning moral and ethical aspects the ethics of human cloning washington. All of my favorite books about clones seem to pose the question what it really. A brave, moral argument for cloning and its power to fight disease. On the surface, the novel presents an unexceptional pulp, postapocalypse. A lucid introduction offers readers an essential overview and understanding of the development and process of cloning, and the editors evenhandedly represent all sides of this controversial subject. Then you can start reading kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer no kindle device required.
Fictional works that deal with cloning as either an important element or the main theme. Both print and electronic resources were used to gather titles of. The technique is, at present, unsafe and the technology is likely to be taken up by such a small proportion of the population that considerations of distributive justice would also support the ban. Applications of gene cloning in medicine, both pdf for diagnosis and treatment, and in the pharmaceutical industry and agriculture, are also covered in the book.
Human cloning developments raise hopes for new treatments. The horrified ethicists are, pence emphasizes, genetic fatalists who cannot entertain new ideas and scientific progress, and science fiction and misunderstandings of what cloning does have helped overwhelm logical discussion. Cloning in young adult fiction uni scholarworks university of. Large scale research cloning could generate a market for womens eggs that could easily lead to. An ethical inquiry 2002, by presidents council on bioethics u. These techniques are some of the basic tools of the trade of modern biomedical research and are not currently a source of much public concern. Cloning is a delicate procedure, and lots can go wrong along the way. In this highly controversial book, john harris does a lot more than ask why we are so afraid of cloning. Gene cloning takes a fresh approach to teaching molecular and cellular biology and will be a valuable resource to both undergraduates and lecturers of biological and biomedical science. The national academy of sciences, while supporting 2001 such socalled therapeutic or research cloning, has opposed 2002 the cloning of humans for reproductive purposes, deeming it unsafe, but many ethicists, religious and political leaders, and others have. Other arguments against cloning focus on the implications for the children who would be produced in cloning experiments.
It should directly contain very few, if any, pages and should mainly contain subcategories. It cannot in itself be used to produce perfect humans or select sex or other traits. Pence points out that many of the arguments against human cloning were used earlier against in vitro fertilization. The paper begins with a laypersons understanding of the science of cloning, before addressing common myths that are associated with the technology. Cloning requires the use of womens eggs, typically ten or more for each attempt.
Jan 25, 2018 t he cloning of macaque monkeys in china makes human reproductive cloning more conceivable. He presents a deft and informed defence of human cloning, carefully exposing the rhetorical and highly dubious arguments against it. Assuming the reader has little prior knowledge of the subject, its importance, the principles of the techniques used and their applications are all. But sometimes, said copies are used in a way thats a bit more unexpected. One corollary of genetic determinism is the mistaken view that genetic identity is equivalent to personal identity. In the cloning sourcebook, raanan gillon examines the arguments against. Read the therapeutic cloning debate global science and journalism in the public sphere by eric a. The purpose of this study was to discover the issues raised about human cloning in young adult fiction.
1538 1236 569 1013 916 507 329 542 830 550 1264 695 1338 1216 1084 707 179 788 1047 627 431 1424 500 673 798 1263 289 650 889 1391 557 814 554 1369 261 775 2 1395 99 884 92